One reason why students are confused is because I believe that high school counselors and English teachers typically don’t understand what elements are necessary to compose an excellent admission essay.
An English paper is an entirely different animal than a college essay.
6, really think that students would rather write on one of the other topics in the Common Application lineup, such as Option No.
4: That snoozer would be better left as an English course assignment.
(The Common Application will reveal the new essay topics, sans Option No. ) In an op-ed in the this fall, Doris Davis, a former board president of the Common Application, diplomatically backed into her concerns about the admission essay change: So why did the Common Application folks make this boneheaded move?
I suspect in part it’s because the people behind the decision weren’t writers.
I surely hope that this isn’t the motivation because I think it is HIGHLY INSULTING to students of color!!!
As a volunteer at my son’s high school in San Diego (High Tech High), I helped many students with their college essays, including the sort of students whom the counselors appear to want to protect.
I’ll give you one example of what I’m talking about.
Like a lot of high school seniors, my nephew Matt originally wrote his college essay in his English class. Louis.) Matt wrote about his pet guinea pig who had recently died.